Clinical Trial Background Issues - page 2
PICO Intervention Issues
The item to be tested in a clinical trial (e.g., new drug, surgical procedure, psychosocial intervention) is described in great detail in a protocol document.
![]() |
This document lists all types of contingencies to ensure that all patients are treated in the same way to produce reliable results. By being very precise, the protocol enables independent researchers to repeat the trial to see if they come up with the same result. Such replication is common in science to ensure that the results that may be used to change clinical practice are real and are not the result of random errors. |
|
The following items are Federal Drug Administration (FDA) standard required protocol elements. They help investigators answer key questions and make sure that participants and health care professionals clearly understand the goals of a clinical trial:
- General information
- Background information (referenced)
- Trial objectives and purpose
- Trial design
- Participant eligibility and withdrawal
- Participant treatment
- Efficacy (will it work?) assessment
- Safety assessment
- Statistics
- Quality control and quality assurance
- Ethics
- Data handling and record keeping
- Financing and insurance
- Publication policy
If government funding is used for the study, the protocol must be reviewed and approved by the National Cancer Institute (NCI).
PICO Comparison Issues
Assessing an experimental intervention properly requires the use of a control (or comparison) intervention so that the two can be compared and contrasted.
The specific conclusions that can be drawn from a clinical trial depend upon what comparisons are specified in the protocol. For example, a new drug may be compared to a placebo (e.g., inactive sugar pill); if patients receiving the new drug live longer, investigators can conclude that the new drug is helpful.
However, they cannot conclude that the trial drug is superior to other drugs that may be used currently. In order to conclude that a new drug is superior to the standard treatment it would have to be compared to the standard treatment in a trial, rather than a placebo.